Court clears way for new Phala Phala evidence leader as EFF and ALPA lose Madonsela bid

By South African Expat News · Sat Nov 14 2026

Court clears way for new Phala Phala evidence leader as EFF and ALPA lose Madonsela bid

Parliament's impeachment inquiry into President Cyril Ramaphosa can now pick a new chief evidence leader. The Western Cape High Court on Friday dismissed applications by the EFF and the African Legal Professionals Association (ALPA) challenging the committee's decision to drop Advocate Thandazani Madonsela SC from the role.

What the court decided

The EFF and ALPA argued that the committee's decision to rescind Madonsela's recommendation was irrational and unlawful, SABC News reported. The case was heard over two days, on 13 and 14 October.

Judge Chantel Fortuin said two judgments had been produced after the court "carefully considered the substantial arguments advanced by all the parties." The majority dismissed both applications, with no order as to costs.

The Houses of Parliament in Cape Town (archive, September 2012). Photo: Dolores Coullie / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
The Houses of Parliament in Cape Town (archive, September 2012). Photo: Dolores Coullie / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Why Madonsela was dropped

Ramaphosa's letter questioned Madonsela's earlier involvement in the matter, including legal advice he gave an ANC study group on the Section 89 process, according to SABC News and The Citizen. The president also pointed to his removal of Madonsela from the Judicial Service Commission in 2022 as a potential source of conflict.

The committee then withdrew its recommendation, reopened the nomination process and put the appointment on hold until the court case was settled.

DateStep
18 August 2026Ramaphosa objects to Madonsela's nomination
13-14 OctoberEFF and ALPA applications argued in court
13 NovemberHigh Court dismisses both applications
Next weekCommittee meets to consider appointing a new evidence leader

Sources: The Citizen, SABC News, Parliament.

What happens next

Gana, a Rise Mzansi MP, welcomed the ruling. "We welcome the judgement and I want to thank our legal team that represented the committee on this matter," he said in a statement issued by Parliament.

In the coming week, we are going to meet as a committee to consider the appointment of a new evidence leader and to finalize the terms of reference.
Makashule Gana, chair of the Impeachment Committee, to eNCA
President Cyril Ramaphosa shakes hands with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen in Brussels (archive, 9 October 2025). Photo: European Commission Audiovisual Service, Christophe Licoppe / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)
President Cyril Ramaphosa shakes hands with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen in Brussels (archive, 9 October 2025). Photo: European Commission Audiovisual Service, Christophe Licoppe / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

The committee had been in the final stages of concluding its terms of reference, and had put the evidence-leader appointment on hold pending the court case, The Citizen reported.

Read on NewsPlatform · More stories